Namechk's pitch is breadth: more than a hundred sites and 36 domain endings in one grid. That's useful if you want to see your name across old blogging platforms and niche communities at a glance.
handle.tools checks 44 platforms on purpose. Each one has its own check, built and tested against a real account and a made-up name before it went live, and re-tested when the platform changes. Instagram, TikTok and X all try to block automated lookups, so a checker can be shown an empty page and report "available" for a name that's taken. We'd rather tell you a result is Likely taken or Could not verify than paint it green.
Instagram is the clearest example: an Instagram "Available" on handle.tools only appears after an extra confirmation step. It takes a second longer, and it's why the green means something.